|
|
Mumbai session’s court accorded 9 accused in the "Best
Bakery case" with life sentences and acquitted 8 others for
lack of evidence. Four others with non-bailable warrants are
still at large. After the Godhra incident where scores Hindu
passengers were mercilessly burnt in an organized fashion by
a Muslim village, riots in Ahmedabad by Hindu mobs targeted
Muslims. Many activists accuse that this was a pogrom
sponsored by Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra Modi. Mobs
attacked Muslims, businesses, and civilians in an organized
and brutal fashion. The case was moved out of Gujarat to
Maharashtra as victims and activists say that they cannot
get justice in Gujarat. The 17 dealt with the court, were
accused of being in this mob. Specifically, they were
accused of unlawful mob assembly, mischief by fire, causing
grievous hurt, and using dangerous weapons. Of the 9, 5 had
additional charges of damage to property, arson, dacoity,
wrongful confinement, and criminal trespass. The "Best
Bakery case" has been mired with controversy after the
prosecution's star witness, Zahira Sheikh, turned hostile
against her sponsor human rights activist and journalist
Teesta Setalvad. Most certainly, this case will go on appeal
as the judge pointed out that the police failed to provide
incontrovertible evidence of special part played by any of
them. This incident was also part of a written debate
between then President Narayanan and Prime Minister
Vajpayee. Narayanan may have breached Constitutional statues
when he outed this secret dialogue and selectively quoting
some of the contents. The Nanavati Commission examining the
riots try to summon those documents but the Government
refuses to divulge the letters seeking Constitutional
privilege stating that the contents of the letter may
seriously damage social structure.
|